Promising Developments in the Cryptocurrency Regulation Bill
Written on
Chapter 1: Introduction to the Lummis-Gillibrand Proposal
On Tuesday, U.S. Senators Cynthia Lummis (R-WY) and Kirsten Gillibrand (D-NY) presented their long-anticipated legislation focused on regulating cryptocurrency. The proposal, known as "The Responsible Financial Innovation Act," has received a generally positive response from advocates within the crypto community. Below are the notable components of the 69-page bill:
Section 1.1: Tax Incentives for Crypto Transactions
This legislation introduces a de minimis exemption from capital gains taxes for profits not exceeding $200. This exemption applies specifically to transactions where individuals use cryptocurrency to purchase goods and services, rather than those conducted through exchanges. This adjustment is expected to enhance the use of Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies as transactional mediums, simplifying tax reporting for users. Initially, the senators had proposed a $600 exemption but opted for the lower figure, believing it would increase the bill’s chances of approval.
Subsection 1.1.1: Additional Tax Revisions
The proposal also addresses significant inconsistencies in the taxation of cryptocurrencies. While the current framework treats crypto as property, taxing gains upon sale, miners are taxed immediately upon mining, treating them as currency producers. This bill aims to rectify this by taxing miners only when they sell the mined coins. Furthermore, non-exchange participants, such as miners, would be exempt from broker reporting requirements, a contentious point from last year’s infrastructure bill. Additionally, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) is tasked with studying various crypto-related events, including airdrops and forks.
Section 1.2: Defining Digital Assets
The bill establishes clear definitions for different types of digital assets. Most cryptocurrencies will be categorized as commodities, governed by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), which includes Bitcoin and Ethereum. In contrast, smaller tokens will be labeled as "Ancillary Assets" and similarly deemed commodities. Tokens that offer dividends or interest, reliant on the efforts of others, will fall under the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) as securities. The bill also calls for collaboration between the SEC and CFTC to develop a self-regulatory organization aimed at improving oversight.
Chapter 2: Addressing Stablecoins and Future Studies
In light of recent collapses in the stablecoin market, the legislation seeks to enforce that all stablecoins are fully backed by cash or equivalents, with regular audits to ensure liquidity for holders. Notably, stablecoin issuers will not be required to register as banks, a departure from the Biden administration's recommendations.
Watch Cynthia Lummis Unveils Bitcoin Strategic Reserve Bill - YouTube
The bill also outlines several areas designated for further study, including:
- 401K Plans: The Government Accountability Office is tasked with assessing the implications of digital assets in retirement accounts.
- Self-Custody Rights: Cryptocurrency holders will have the right to manage their own coins, as opposed to relying solely on exchanges.
- Consumer Protections: Issuers must disclose comprehensive information about their products, including risks and legal status.
- Energy Consumption: A study on the energy usage associated with cryptocurrency will be conducted by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission in conjunction with the CFTC and SEC.
- Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs): Several U.S. agencies will analyze China’s CBDC initiatives.
NOTABLE: The bill's sponsors, Lummis and Gillibrand, represent states with contrasting political leanings—Wyoming and New York. There is potential for the bill to be divided into smaller parts, enhancing the likelihood of passing crucial aspects. Gillibrand is optimistic about the bill progressing through various Senate committees, anticipating support on the floor.
While the legislative process may be lengthy, updates will be provided as developments occur. Stay tuned for more information.
Thanks for reading, and please share this newsletter.
Subscribe on Substack — Always Free!
Watch Senate Bill Would Treat Crypto Like Commodities - YouTube